The untold backstage drama that shook Broadway and nearly changed the course of Streisand’s career.
Before Barbra Streisand became a global icon, she faced one of the most painful professional battles of her young life — right in the heart of Broadway.
A breakthrough role that sparked backstage tension
In 1962, Streisand joined the cast of I Can Get It for You Wholesale. Though her character was a supporting role, she stunned audiences night after night. Her rising spotlight, however, stirred resentment among some cast members. Reports from the time suggested certain performers felt overshadowed, claiming that the director made changes favoring Streisand, even altering scenes to highlight her presence.
The breaking point — a harsh remark that cut deep
One veteran cast member allegedly told her after a rehearsal:
“You don’t belong on Broadway. You break every rule.”
The comment devastated Streisand. She considered quitting theatre altogether — until an unexpected twist changed everything.
The New York Times published a glowing review of her performance, calling her “a new and irresistible force on the Broadway stage.”
From controversy to legend
The chaos around this role catapulted Streisand to her first major leading part — Funny Girl — a performance that earned her worldwide fame and an Oscar.
Why this story matters today
It reveals a side of Streisand that many forget: she didn’t begin as a beloved superstar, but as a bold newcomer who challenged tradition. And sometimes, greatness begins exactly where resistance is strongest.